Two different rooms

Product Hunt and Show HN are often mentioned in the same breath, but they are different rooms with different audiences and different etiquette. Treating them the same is one of the most common launch mistakes.

Product Hunt is a launch platform built around daily rankings of new products. The audience is broad: makers, early adopters, marketers, investors and people who like trying new tools. Presentation matters. A clear tagline, good images and an engaged maker in the comments all help.

Show HN is a post type on Hacker News for sharing something you made that people can try. The audience skews technical and is quick to question claims, marketing language and anything that feels like an ad. Substance and a genuine build story matter more than polish.

Neither is required. Many successful products never launched on either. But if your audience overlaps with one of them, a well-prepared post can bring a useful burst of early users and feedback.

Is either one right for your product?

A rough guide:

Your product Product Hunt Show HN
Consumer app or general productivity tool Often a good fit Sometimes, if there is an interesting technical angle
Developer tool or open-source project Can work Often a strong fit
Niche B2B tool for a non-technical industry Limited reach to real buyers Usually a poor fit
AI wrapper with little original work Crowded Likely to draw criticism
Game or creative experiment Can work Can work, especially if it is playful and free to try

If your real users are dentists or landscapers, neither venue is likely to reach many of them. You may be better served by the channels in Finding Your First 100 Users.

Preparing for Product Hunt

Product Hunt rewards preparation. Before launch day:

  • Write a plain tagline. Say what the product does in a short sentence. Avoid superlatives.
  • Prepare images and a short video that show the actual product in use.
  • Write a first comment explaining why you built it, who it is for and what is special about it. Keep it personal and short.
  • Have a clear offer for visitors, such as an extended trial. Keep it modest.
  • Make sure signup works on mobile and on a slow connection.
  • Tell your existing audience that you are launching, and ask them to check it out and share honest feedback. Do not ask for upvotes; platforms discourage it, and it cheapens the result.

Launch timing matters mostly relative to the platform's daily cycle. Check the current guidance on the platform itself, since conventions change.

Preparing for Show HN

Show HN has stricter expectations, and the community enforces them.

  • It must be something people can try. Not a waitlist, not a landing page, not a signup wall in front of everything. A live demo or a free tier is ideal.
  • Title it plainly. "Show HN: " followed by the name and a short, factual description.
  • Write a short text post explaining what it is, why you built it and anything interesting about how it works. Technical detail is welcome.
  • Be ready for blunt feedback. Some comments will be sharp. Many will be useful.
  • Read the posting guidelines before you submit. They are short and they matter.

If you are open source, link the repository. Many GitHub entries in this catalog were first shared this way.

On the day

The behaviour that helps is the same on both platforms: be present, be honest, be brief.

  • Reply to every genuine comment, especially questions and criticism. Thank people for their time.
  • Answer the question that was asked. Do not paste marketing copy into replies.
  • Admit limitations. "It does not support that yet" is a fine answer. People respect it more than evasion.
  • Log every piece of feedback in a notes file as it arrives.
  • Fix small bugs live if you can, and say so in the thread.
  • Do not argue. If someone is wrong about your product, correct the fact once, politely, and move on.

Keep your error logs open in another tab. Launch day is when edge cases arrive all at once.

What to expect afterward

Traffic from either venue usually looks like a spike: a sharp rise on the day, a smaller tail for a day or two, and then back to near where you started. That is normal and not a sign that something went wrong.

To put it in hypothetical terms: say your Show HN post brings 3,000 visitors over two days. If 4% sign up, that is 120 accounts. If a third of those activate and a handful pay, you have a small but real group of early users, plus a thread full of feedback. That is a good outcome, even though the traffic graph will look like a cliff a week later.

What matters more than the peak:

  • Who signed up and why. Email them and ask.
  • What people misunderstood. Confusion in comments tells you what to fix on your landing page.
  • Which features people asked for most. Look for repeated requests, not the loudest single one.
  • Whether anyone came back without a reminder.

Common mistakes

  • Launching before the product works reliably. A broken signup on launch day wastes your one big spike.
  • Treating the ranking as the goal. A mid-table finish with engaged users beats a top spot full of drive-by visitors.
  • Recruiting upvote rings. It can get your post penalized or removed, and it misleads you about real interest.
  • Disappearing after posting. A launch without the maker in the comments reads as abandoned.
  • Launching on every platform on the same day. You cannot be present in five threads at once.

Relaunching

Both communities allow some form of relaunch or reposting after meaningful changes, but the rules differ and can change. If your first attempt got little attention, it is often worth trying again after a significant update, with a clearer pitch. Check each platform's current rules first.

FAQ

Do I need a hunter or an existing audience?

Not necessarily. An existing audience helps, but many makers launch successfully on their own. A clear product and an attentive maker count for more.

Which should I do first?

If your product is technical and has a live demo, Show HN is a natural first step. If it is more visual and aimed at a broad audience, Product Hunt may suit it better. Doing them a few weeks apart lets you give each one your full attention.

Is a low-ranked launch a failure?

No. The ranking is a byproduct. What matters is whether the right people found the product and whether you learned something you could act on.

Related reading